HELOC vs Mortgage: Which is Right for You?
Introduction
Are you sitting on thousands of dollars in home equity but unsure how to access it? With Vancouver homeowners holding an average of $300,000 or more in equity, choosing the right financial product can mean the difference between achieving your goals and getting trapped in a cycle of debt.
Whether you're planning a major kitchen renovation, consolidating high-interest credit card debt, or looking to invest in a rental property, understanding the difference between a HELOC and a traditional mortgage is essential. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada reports that HELOCs have become the single largest contributor to non-mortgage household debt in Canada—more than double that of either credit cards or auto loans—making it critical to understand how these products work before committing.
In this comprehensive guide, you'll learn exactly how HELOCs and mortgages differ, when to use each option, current rates in BC, and how to determine which product aligns with your financial goals. By the end, you'll have the confidence to make an informed decision about unlocking your home equity.
Table of Contents
Listen to the podcast: HELOC vs Mortgage?
Understanding HELOCs and Mortgages: The Fundamentals
What is a HELOC?
A Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) is a revolving line of credit secured against the equity in your home. Think of it as a large, reusable credit card with a much lower interest rate—you're approved for a maximum limit, can borrow as needed, repay, and borrow again within that limit.
According to the Government of Canada, with a HELOC you only pay interest on the amount you borrow, not the entire credit limit. Your home acts as collateral, which is why lenders can offer rates significantly lower than unsecured credit products.
HELOCs typically feature a draw period lasting 5-10 years where you can access funds freely, followed by a repayment period of 10-20 years. During the draw period, most lenders require only interest payments, though you can pay down the principal at any time without penalty.
What is a Mortgage?
A traditional mortgage is a loan used to purchase or refinance a home. Unlike a HELOC, you receive all the funding upfront as a lump sum and repay it over a fixed term—typically 25 years or more in Canada.
Mortgages offer predictable payment schedules and the choice between fixed-rate options (where your rate stays constant) and variable-rate options (where your rate fluctuates with the prime rate). Once you make a principal payment on a regular mortgage, you must refinance to access that money again—a process that can be expensive and time-consuming.
Key Differences Between HELOCs and Mortgages
Borrowing Structure and Flexibility
The fundamental difference lies in how you access and repay funds:
HELOC:
Revolving credit—borrow, repay, and borrow again
Pay interest only on amounts withdrawn
Flexible repayment with interest-only minimums
No need to reapply for additional funds within your limit
Mortgage:
One-time lump sum disbursement
Fixed payment schedule over the term
Principal and interest payments required
Must refinance to access additional equity
For Vancouver homeowners managing ongoing expenses like phased renovations or investment opportunities, a HELOC provides the flexibility to access funds when needed without repeatedly applying for new financing.
Interest Rate Structures
Understanding how interest rates work for each product is crucial for long-term planning:
Most HELOCs carry variable interest rates tied to the lender's prime rate—typically prime plus 0.5% to 1%. As Ratehub.ca explains, when the Bank of Canada adjusts its overnight lending rate, lenders adjust their prime rates accordingly, directly affecting your HELOC payments.
Mortgages offer more variety: you can lock in a fixed rate for stability or choose a variable rate that moves with prime. With Canada's prime rate currently at 4.45% following the Bank of Canada's October 2025 rate cut, both products have become more affordable compared to the 7.20% prime rate seen in mid-2023.
Repayment Terms and Requirements
HELOC minimum payments typically cover only interest, offering lower monthly obligations but potentially extending your debt timeline indefinitely. According to NerdWallet Canada, mortgage repayment happens on a strictly defined schedule set by your lender, and there may be steep penalties for early repayment depending on the mortgage type.
This structural difference matters significantly for your long-term financial health. Research from the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada found that most consumers do not repay their HELOC in full until they sell their home—a pattern that can erode your wealth over time if not managed carefully.
Current Rates and Borrowing Limits in BC
2025 Rate Environment
The Bank of Canada has implemented multiple rate cuts since June 2024, bringing the overnight rate down from 5% to 2.25% as of October 2025. This has created a more favorable borrowing environment for BC homeowners:
Current HELOC Rates: Prime + 0.5% to Prime + 1%, translating to approximately 4.95% to 5.45% for well-qualified borrowers at major banks.
Current Mortgage Rates: Variable mortgages are often priced below prime (prime minus 0.5% to 1%), while 5-year fixed rates range from approximately 4.19% to 5.29% depending on your qualifications and lender.
Borrowing Limits in Canada
Federal regulations from OSFI (Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions) set clear limits on home equity borrowing:
Standalone HELOC: Maximum 65% of your home's appraised value
Combined HELOC + Mortgage: Maximum 80% of your home's value (with the mortgage accounting for at least 15%)
Example for Vancouver Homeowners: If your home is valued at $1,200,000 and you owe $400,000 on your mortgage, you have $800,000 in equity. A standalone HELOC could provide access to up to $780,000 (65% of value), though your actual limit would be calculated as: ($1,200,000 × 65%) - $400,000 = $380,000.
When to Choose a HELOC vs a Mortgage
Choose a HELOC When:
You need flexible access to funds over time. HELOCs excel for ongoing projects like phased home renovations, educational expenses spread over multiple years, or maintaining an emergency fund backed by your home equity.
You want to consolidate high-interest debt. With rates significantly lower than credit cards (often 19.99%+), a HELOC can help you pay down consumer debt faster. However, discipline is essential—the FCAC warns that using a HELOC for debt consolidation without a clear repayment plan can worsen your financial position.
You're making investments. Some Vancouver homeowners use HELOCs for investment strategies like the Smith Manoeuvre, where HELOC interest used for investment purposes may be tax-deductible (consult a tax professional for your specific situation).
You're self-employed or have variable income. The interest-only payment option provides flexibility during slower business periods while allowing aggressive paydown during profitable months.
Choose a Mortgage When:
You're purchasing a home. A traditional mortgage is the primary tool for home purchases, allowing you to finance up to 95% of a property's value with CMHC insurance (or 80% without insurance).
You need predictable payments for budgeting. Fixed-rate mortgages provide payment stability that many families rely on for long-term financial planning.
You prefer forced savings. The required principal payments on a mortgage ensure you're building equity with every payment—something that interest-only HELOC payments don't accomplish.
You're refinancing for a specific, one-time expense. When you know exactly how much you need and want structured repayment, mortgage refinancing often provides lower rates than a HELOC.
The Hybrid Approach: Readvanceable Mortgages
Many BC homeowners benefit from a readvanceable mortgage—a combined product that includes both a traditional mortgage and a HELOC under one umbrella. As you pay down your mortgage principal, your available HELOC credit automatically increases. Products like TD's Home Equity FlexLine and Scotiabank's STEP offer this flexibility, allowing you to access up to 80% of your home's value while maintaining the structure of mortgage payments.
Risks and Considerations for Vancouver Homeowners
HELOC Risks to Understand
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada has conducted extensive research on HELOC usage, finding several concerning patterns:
Over-borrowing: Easy access to credit can lead to spending beyond your means. FCAC research found that 19% of HELOC holders borrowed more than they originally intended.
Debt persistence: With interest-only minimums, your balance can remain unchanged for years. More than 25% of HELOC holders routinely make only interest payments, yet 62% of these borrowers optimistically expect to repay their full balance within 5 years.
Variable rate exposure: When rates rise, so do your payments. The rate increases from 2022-2023 saw HELOC rates jump from under 4% to over 7%, significantly impacting monthly costs.
Home at risk: Both HELOCs and mortgages use your home as collateral. If you cannot make payments, the lender can ultimately enforce a sale or foreclosure.
Vancouver-Specific Considerations
With Metro Vancouver's benchmark home price at $1,132,500 as of October 2025 (down 3.4% year-over-year according to the Greater Vancouver REALTORS®), homeowners should consider:
Market fluctuations: Your borrowing limit is tied to your home's appraised value. If property values decline significantly, your lender could reduce your HELOC limit.
High-value properties: Vancouver's expensive real estate means even modest percentage declines represent substantial dollar amounts.
Rate sensitivity: With large mortgages common in Metro Vancouver, even small rate changes significantly impact monthly payments.
Protecting Yourself
Before accessing home equity through either product:
Create a clear repayment plan with a defined timeline
Avoid using HELOCs for daily expenses or to live beyond your means
Consider locking in portions of your HELOC balance at fixed rates when available
Work with a mortgage broker who can compare options across multiple lenders
FAQs
Can I use a HELOC to buy another property?
Yes, you can use HELOC funds as a down payment for an investment property or second home. In Canada, you can finance up to 65% of a property's purchase price with a HELOC. If you want to finance more, you must combine it with a mortgage, ensuring total financing doesn't exceed 80% of the home's value. Many Vancouver investors use this strategy to build real estate portfolios.
What credit score do I need for a HELOC in BC?
Major banks typically require a credit score of 650 or higher for HELOC approval, though 680+ is preferred for the best rates. You'll also need at least 20% equity in your home, verifiable income, and a debt-to-income ratio under 40%. If you don't meet these criteria, B-lenders and private lenders offer HELOC options with more flexible requirements at higher rates.
How quickly can I access funds from a HELOC vs refinancing my mortgage?
Once your HELOC is established, you can access funds instantly via online banking, debit card, or cheques—much like a bank account. Mortgage refinancing, however, requires a new application, appraisal, legal documentation, and typically takes 2-4 weeks to complete. This makes HELOCs far more convenient for time-sensitive needs.
Are HELOC interest payments tax-deductible in Canada?
Generally, HELOC interest is not tax-deductible when used for personal expenses. However, if you use HELOC funds for investment purposes (such as purchasing income-generating investments), the interest may be tax-deductible. This is the foundation of strategies like the Smith Manoeuvre. Always consult a qualified tax professional before implementing such strategies.
What happens to my HELOC if I sell my home?
When you sell your home, you must repay your HELOC balance in full from the sale proceeds before receiving any remaining equity. Your HELOC is registered as a lien against your property, so the lender will be paid at closing. Ensure you factor your HELOC balance into your calculations when planning to sell.
Conclusion
Choosing between a HELOC and a mortgage depends entirely on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and how you plan to use the funds. HELOCs offer unmatched flexibility for ongoing expenses, debt consolidation, and investment opportunities—but require discipline to avoid the pitfalls of easy credit access and indefinite debt.
Traditional mortgages provide structure, predictability, and forced savings through required principal payments, making them ideal for home purchases and one-time large expenses where you want a clear payoff timeline.
For many Vancouver homeowners, a readvanceable mortgage combining both products offers the best of both worlds: the stability of mortgage payments with the flexibility of HELOC access as you build equity.
The key is working with an experienced mortgage professional who understands your complete financial picture and can guide you toward the right solution for your specific situation.
Ready to unlock your home equity the smart way? Whether you're considering a HELOC, mortgage refinancing, or want to explore your options, I'm here to help you navigate the decision with personalized guidance.
📞 Call Bill Karalash at 604-265-5858 or Schedule a Free Consultation to discuss which option is right for your Vancouver home.
About the Author: Bill Karalash is a licensed Sub-Mortgage Broker (License #MB610235) operating under Breezeful Brokerage (License #MB601942) in Vancouver, BC. Serving the Greater Vancouver area and all of British Columbia, Bill provides personalized mortgage solutions including pre-approvals, refinancing, renewals, HELOCs, and private mortgages. Contact Bill today to start your mortgage journey.
Sources:
